|
“Battlestar
Galactica-Season One (U.S. Release)“
|
 |
Reviewed
by: |
Wayne A. Klein |
| Genre: |
Science Fiction
|
| Video: |
1.78:1 Anamorphic
Widescreen |
| Audio: |
Dolby Digital
5.1 |
| Languages |
English |
| Subtitles |
English |
| Length |
Approximately
672 minutes (including extras and deleted scenes) |
| Rating |
NR |
| Release Date |
9/21/05 |
| Studio |
Universal
Home Entertainment |
| Commentary:
|
Nine commentary
tracks |
| Documentaries:
|
“Battlestar
Galatica: The Low Down |
| Featurettes:
|
“Change is Good, Now
They’re Babies”, “The Cylon Centurion”, “Future/Past Technology”,
“The Doctor is Out (of his Mind)”, “Production”, “Visual Effects”,
“Epilogue” |
| Filmography/Biography:
|
None |
|
Interviews: |
None |
| Trailers/TV
Spots: |
None |
| Alternate/Deleted
Scenes: |
Alternate
opening for international broadcast, deleted scenes |
| Music
Video: |
None |
| Other:
|
“Sketches
& Art”, Trading Card |
| Cast
and Crew: |
Edward James
Olmos, Mary McDonnell, Katee Sackhoff, Jamie Bamber, James Callis,
Tricia Helfer, Grace Park |
| Written
By: |
Ronald D.
Moore, Bradley Thompson, David Weddle |
| Produced
By: |
Ronald D.
Moore |
| Directed
By: |
Edward James
Olmos, Michael Rymer, Brad Turner |
| Music:
|
Richard Gibbs
|
| The
Review: |
The official release of “Battlestar
Galatica finally arrives on DVD a mere six months after its
official UK release and two plus months after the Best Buy
UK release. The differences are substantial; the U.K. release
was mostly bare bones while the U.S. release features a number
of extras not included on the other edition plus the extras
included there as well. Fans take note this includes both
the mini-series and the regular first season. ***
Universal has done an exceptional
job with the transfer here; “Battlestar Galatica” looks terrific
with vivid colors, nice, sharp detail. You’ll notice grain
during the mini-series that isn’t apparent during the TV show—that’s
because the mini-series was shot on film and the TV show on
HD video. The grain adds grit to the series and I didn’t notice
it on the original DVD single disc release but, surprise,
surprise it was there. It appears that this is the exact same
transfer as previously available. There’s a bit of noticeable
noise during the series itself but its not too distracting.
I’m surprised that Universal couldn’t clean up the bit of
digital video noise that is evident here but perhaps it’s
a problem with the original videotape. that is in use in the
United States and Canada. The 5.1 sound comes across with
awesome power and presence and sounds exceptionally crisp
and sharp even in the 2.0 format. Overall, an exceptional
job despite some minor analog and digital blemishes, “Battlestar
Galatica” looks better than most transfers that Universal
has done for TV series. ***
|
| Image
and Sound: |
Universal has done an exceptional
job with the transfer here; “Battlestar Galatica” looks terrific
with vivid colors, nice, sharp detail. You’ll notice grain
during the mini-series that isn’t apparent during the TV show—that’s
because the mini-series was shot on film and the TV show on
HD video. The grain adds grit to the series and I didn’t notice
it on the original DVD single disc release but, surprise,
surprise it was there. It appears that this is the exact same
transfer as previously available. There’s a bit of noticeable
noise during the series itself but its not too distracting.
I’m surprised that Universal couldn’t clean up the bit of
digital video noise that is evident here but perhaps it’s
a problem with the original videotape. that is in use in the
United States and Canada. The 5.1 sound comes across with
awesome power and presence and sounds exceptionally crisp
and sharp even in the 2.0 format. Overall, an exceptional
job despite some minor analog and digital blemishes, “Battlestar
Galatica” looks better than most transfers that Universal
has done for TV series. ***
A note for international fans of
the show with multi-region players; this set only includes
the original English language 5.1 mix. It doesn’t have the
French and Spanish tracks that were available on the mini-series.
Subtitles are available for those languages thought. Something
to be aware of English isn’t your first language and you planned
on listening to the series in your native tongue. ---
|
| The
Extras: |
I have
good and bad news. There are eight featurettes but they aren’t
new exactly. All were available online at the Sci-Fi Channel
website. All are quite good and its nice to have them in a
permanent format. Image and sound quality are better than
the website versions. There’s also a short documentary on
the series entitled “Battlestar Galatica: The Lowdown”. It’s
essentially the same short documentary that was available
on the mini-series release. The bad news is that nothing else
from the mini-series is included outside of the commentary
track for the min-series. ***
The deleted
scenes that were available on the Best Buy UK release are
available here as well. There’s also a trading card for each
set. There’s also a montage of sketches and artwork from the
first season included as well. ---
|
| Commentary:
|
There are
total of 10 commentary tracks including the original commentary
track from the mini-series. Half of these were done as Podcasts
and were available on the Sci-Fi Channel website. The rest feature
series developer/producer/writer Ronald Moore with his co-producer
David Eick. All are exceptionally well done but you’ll note
that the better commentary tracks (no surprise here folks) are
the ones done for the best episodes. |
| Final
Words: |
This is
definitely the superior set for “Battlestar Galatica” fans.
The fact that it also has the international opening gives fans
even less reason to keep the UK set. It might become a collectible
someday but other than that there’s really no reason to keep
that set vs. this one. Image quality despite a few minor exceptions
is stellar as is the sound. There are commentary tracks for
9 episodes and these include the Podcasts that Ronald Moore
started doing for the Sci-Fi Channel website. |