movie reviews movie review
Search Archives DVD Mall Prog Land TV Contact Us Reviewer Bio


Search Movie Review Archives

0-9 A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
 
About DVDivas
Dvdivas was founded by John Gabbard in 2000. It's purpose has been and remains to be to provide you, the entertainment community with the latest dvds and movie reviews. It will continue to be your link to the most popular dvd movies.

 

"Warner Bros.Gangster Collection, Volume 3”
Reviewer:
Wayne Klein
Studio: Warner Brothers
Genre: Action
Release:
4/5/08
Special Features: Commentary tracks, "Warner Night at the Movies" theatrical featurettes, shorts, newsreels, trailers
Review:

Prior to the Breen code being put into place, Gangsters had it easy in the movies--they could gamble on screen and not be punished for their evil deeds. What's more they could be complex, multi-dimensional characters that had an element of good in them in addition to the overwhelming bad elements. The quality of the films varies but the best here more than hold their own against the best in the genre. More importantly, most of these films were made prior to the code taking effect (which was in 1934 when Breen could enforce the strict guidelines of the code making sure there was "morality" on the screen and that the wicked were punished). ***

First up is "Smart Money" the only film to feature Edgar G. Robinson, James Cagney and, in a supporting role, Boris Karloff (post-Frankenstein pre-fame when it was shot). Robinson plays Nick Venizelos a man who runs much more than his barber shop; he's got plenty of gambling and other parlor games running on the side. When Nick is ripped off in a big stakes poker game, he plans his revenge to get the $10,000 that he and his pals put up as his stake. Cagney primarily has a supporting role. "Little Caesar" had become a big hit but "Public Enemy" had yet to be released so while his star was on the rise, it wasn't quite as high as Robinson's at the time. ***

Well made with a breezy pace and some particularly nice camera dollies and shots (remember, this was early in the days of sound films when doing a dolly shot was like moving a mountain). It's a very good film in spite of some flawed plotting on the part of the (four credited) writers. ***

Cagney gets center stage for "Picture Snatcher" where he plays an ex-con who gets a job as a newspaper photographer (!). He'll do anything for scoop and sometimes that "anything goes" attitude can cost him. Featuring able support by Ralph Bellamy, "Picture Snatcher" is a surprisingly strong programmer with a breakneck pace for a 1930's picture. Unfortunately due to a flaw in the original disc (some sort of manufacturing snafu I'd imagine) I couldn't view the entire film. ***

"The Mayor of Hell" is, perhaps, the most dated of the package. Directed by Archie Mayo (best known for the radio drama "Lights Out" and for directing one of the first 3-D movies in the 50's), "The Mayor of Hell" has a major Achilles Heel--the writing. The writers provide us with a "moral" story dealing with social commentary but stumbles with the racial stereotypes of the time. Cagney stars again but he's clearly in a supporting role here as well; he plays ***

"Lady Killer" and "Black Legion" are up next and are memorable as much for what we see as what we don't because of the Code. The former is a parody of Hollywood mixed with a gangster film in a bizarre genetic monstrosity directed by Roy Del Ruth. When former movie usher Dan (Cagney) has a con pulled by a grafter (Mae Clarke), Dan tracks her down and forces his way into the gang that her brother (Douglas Dumbrille) runs. ***

"Black Legion" deals with prejudice with Humphrey Bogart as a down-on-his luck guy who loses his a promotion and hears a radio broadcast attacking the foreigners that are stealing jobs from able bodied Americans. In this case, the film is a less than subtle jab at the Klu Klux Klan or any other hate group. Frank joins this "Black Legion" an organization much like the Klan. He finds friends and others with a chip on their shoulder and hits the high life again able to buy all those things he always wanted but at what cost? It's an interesting film in that "Black Legion" does deal with racism but doesn't point the finger at the Klan nor does it bring up the victims of this form of racism. ***

"Brother Orchid" is probably the best known of the films in this set and while it is enjoyable it isn't Robinson or Bogart's best film by a long shot. Robinson plays Johnny a gangster who left the "business" behind in the charge of his second in command Buck (Bogart). When Johnny returns, he wants what is rightfully his and gets shot in the process. He doesn't die however and is found by a group of monks who treat his wounds and allow him to stay at the monastery they call home. Turns out that while Johnny plays his racket at the monastery when Buck tries the same thing Johnny becomes protective of his new "brothers". ---

Image & Sound:

All the films look quite good with a minimal amount of grain and artifacts. The films have been cleaned up and the best available prints have been used to reconstruct the films from this set. Audio sounds as you would expect period audio to sound--it doesn't have a lot of life to it but just the right amount of noise reduction is used to reduce the crackle of the period soundtrack. ---

Special Features:

Each film comes with a commentary with Alan Gansberg and Eric Lax a pair of film historians doing the best job on "Brother Orchid". Second prize for best commentary goes to historians Anthony Slide and Patricia Hanson who provide the commentary for the allegorical "Black Legion". Each film also comes with a "Warner Night at the Movies" with vintage newsreels, shorts and a variety of other things you might have seen if you were there when these films were released to theaters in their respective years.

Final Words:

A terrific set with a mixed bag of films, "Gangsters Collection 3" has its moments even in the weakest of the films included here and each film has a terrific performance by either Cagney, Robinson or Bogart (sometimes in pairs no less!). This is a worthwhile set for fans of vintage gangster flicks and melodramas.

 

 
 
 
Copyright @ Teakwood Productions 2000
Home News DVDWorld DVDLand(Links) DVDVoices
Search Archives DVD Mall Prog Land TV Contact Us Reviewer's Bio
Upcoming DVDs In Theatres Soon Other Popular Reviews
This Page Design By Dominion Technology Provider
 
In Theatres Soon Upcoming DVDs Alias Tomb Raider Casablanca NYPD Blues