Review Archives

1 | 2 | 3

Today's Date is:

Innocence


Reviewed by: David Litton
Genre: Drama
Video: 1.85:1 anamorphic widescreen
Audio: English Dolby Digital 5.1, French Dolby Digital 2.0
Language: English, French
Subtitle: English, French, Spanish
Length: 96 min
Rating: R
Release Date: 12/10/2002
Studio: Columbia Tristar Home Entertainment
Commentary: None
Documentaries: None
Featurettes: None
Filmography/Biography: None
Interviews: None
Trailers/TV Spots: Theatrical trailers
Alternate/Deleted Scenes: None
Music Video: None
Other: None
Cast and Crew: Julia Blake, Charles Tingwell, Terry Norris, Robert Menzies
Written By: Paul Cox
Produced by: Paul Cox, Mark Patterson
Directed By: Paul Cox
Music: Paul Grabowsky
The Review:

"Innocence" just might be the most intelligent film about love ever made, simply because it accepts the fact that love cannot, and should not, be explained. So many films make the fatal mistake of digging too deep into melodrama in search of an explanation for their characters' feelings, failing to realize that the best love stories are those that simply allow the emotion to blossom and bloom. ***

But the film does not stop there; instead, it throws a one-two punch by choosing to focus on a story involving elderly people rather than the young, nubile bodies intertwined amongst one another that we have become so accustomed to seeing onscreen over the years. Sex is almost always delegated to the young in movies, as well as in real life; we never stop to think that older people remain active in their love lives long after they hit a certain age. Writer/director Paul Cox is able to balance these two potent issues with one another in a way that is truly heartfelt and touching; he shows a skill that many filmmakers lack in these matters, and his film is all the better for it. ***

The beginning of the film is composed of a series of images of two young people riding bicycles, frolicking in the woods, the sort of romantic haze that captures the youthful generation before they have a chance to realize it. This takes place in the memory of Andreas (Charles Tingwell), an elderly man in his seventies who has looked up his first true love, Claire (Julia Blake), in hopes that they might catch up on old times and remain friends. Their initial meeting is one of hearty recollections and good-spirited friendship, but afterwards, that feeling of separation that each of us has experienced in one form or another sets in. Andreas cannot go for one day without calling Claire, recording letters on his tape recorder, or simply thinking of her and their times together. ***

At first hesitant, Claire soon breaks down and agrees to meet him at a cemetery, where the remains of his wife are being moved to a new location. The experience is too much for him; in his grief, Claire consoles him, and the two end up spending the night together. Upon returning home the next day, she admits the act to her husband, John (Terry Norris), who first passes it off as a ploy for attention. At this point, she begins to realize that the life she has lived has been more out of comfort than anything else, and by rekindling her love with Andreas, she realizes she has found the life she has been looking for. ***

The way the events of the film are handled are simply extraordinary, ultimately transcending the boundaries of simplicity to become something wholly complex and complicated. Anyone who has ever been in love can identify with Andreas and Claire: they experience emotional changes so vast, and yet so attuned to our own personal experiences that they could easily be our own. That they have held on to these emotions for more than forty years is a testament to the fact that some love never truly dies, and just as these two people have no idea why they embark on this journey together, we ourselves need to realize that sometimes love itself has no explanation. It defies logic and reason, and has a mind and heart of its own. ***

And just like love itself, there are moments in this film that are indescribable, akin to the very feeling of love itself. Cox's screenplay and quiet, understated direction provide one of the most incredibly touching looks at tenderness I've ever seen, anchored by two of the most profoundly moving performances of the year. Julia Blake and Charles Tingwell act with great courage and conviction, their performances full of ambition, realistic emotional intrigue, and an honesty that goes unmatched by a great many predecessors. More than anything else, they bring us into the film and keep us there, binding us to their love affair while also giving us reason to care for them as individuals. That they happen to be much older than the usual movie couple hardly seems to be of any importance once things develop further; we come to feel for them as much as we would feel for any other couple, be it that of "Titanic" or "Gone With the Wind." ***

It is precisely that focus that puts everything about "Innocence" into perspective. In the end, love is not about age, nor is it about trying to figure out and decipher the feeling as if it were Morse Code. This film gets back to the essential factor of the feeling, that indescribable shockwave that you can't quite explain, but you know is there. John Lennon once said, "All you need is love;" this is that love.

Image and Sound

In almost all respects, the 1.85:1 image for "Innocence" is a love affair in itself. Colors are wonderfully saturated for just the right feel, while fleshtones are always accurate and warm. Contrast, though flawed in minor instances, is otherwise great, with terrific shadow delineation and deep, pure blacks. Edges sometimes have a soft appearance, no doubt the result of stylistic influences, but when they are sharp, detail is exquisite. There is some noticeable film grain, but nothing too intrusive. A fine picture transfer throughout. ***

The Dolby Digital 5.1 track is a mostly dialogue-driven track, so don't expect too much in terms of ear-bleeding sound effects and deep bass. With the exception of scenes involving flashbacks (even those tend to remain confined to the front end), much of the movie is all talk, but it sounds clean and remained centered throughout. The music is somewhat low in volume, and generally leans towards the front, but there is some activity in the surrounds.

The Extras Nothing but some trailers
Commentary None
Final Words: Sorry to say, this is another bare-bones release for a truly remarkable film. When is Columbia TriStar going to realize that the Sony Pictures Classics films have more weight than some of their big-budget flops?


Send all Comments to Teakwood Productions
February 9, 2003