|
|
|
Search Movie Review
Archives
|
|
|
| |
| Dvdivas
was founded by John Gabbard in 2000. It's purpose has been and
remains to be to provide you, the entertainment community with
the latest dvds and movie reviews. It will continue to be your
link to the most popular dvd movies. |
|
|
|
“The
New World”
|
|
Reviewer:
|
Wayne
A. Klein
|
Studio: |
New Line |
| Genre: |
Drama |
Release:
|
5/9/06 |
| Special
Features: |
A ten part documentary on the
making of “The New World”, theatrical trailer |
| Review:
|
It’s a miracle when Terence Malick finishes a film.His
work appears so rarely that it’s almost like an act of God
when a finished film finally premieres by the press shy
writer/director. “The New World” offered the perfect canvas
for what Malick does best but fails to live up to expectations.
At over two and a half hours “The New World” is lost at
sea without a rudder, map or a clue as to which direction
to turn. Malick tackles the story of John Smith and Pocahontas
has already been tackled and the fact that this rich fairytale
has defied the ability of Hollywood to make it a moving,
powerful epic love story says as much about the inadequacies
of Hollywood at modern day storytelling as it does about
the difficulty of telling the tale. With over 1 million
feet of film shot for this epic love story/adventure Malick
seems to lose the narrative thread that could have made
for a compelling powerful story. Perhaps it was Malick’s
decision to cut the film to James Horner score that undermined
the film either way it’s clear that the director lost his
way in the process of making his film. I would have thought
that Malick would have been one of the few people that could
have done this story well. Unfortunately, his screenplay
(which is nearly twenty years old) hasn’t aged well. The
dialogue is hamfisted and sounds overwrought. Whatever updates
he made to his original script haven’t translated well to
the screen either. Because this is a film by Malick you
know it’ll be visually breathtaking and “The New World”
captures the rich color, detail and power of the tale visually
it’s just the narrative that fails to live up to its potential.
Image & Sound:
An exceptional transfer for “The New World” highlights
this release. Shot on 65mm film the stunning visual compositions
and cinematography burst off the screen with a depth and
clarity that reminds us how good the DVD format can be when
the source is as rich as this and the transfer as meticulous.
The audio sounds as grand as the impressive visuals with
a rich, detailed 5.1 transfer that spreads effects around
well creating an aural environment that envelopes the viewer.
---
|
| Special
Features: |
Without an audio commentary it’s
hard to figure out if Malick realized where his film went
wrong. Much like “The Thin Red Line” Malick’s film has a narrative
that hasn’t been fully digested and, as a result, the raw
dialogue and story structure undermines the integrity of this
fine looking film. The documentary on the film misses the
central character of this film—the director. Malick avoids
cameras like the plague but here some explanation would have
been helpful to understand how he shaped the vision for this
film. While the documentary does provide us with plenty of
detail about the behind-the-scenes pre through post production
process we’re missing the most important element of the story.
It’s like making a movie without the central character. Running
about an hour the documentary is decent but lacking the depth
I would have expected. We also get the original theatrical
trailer as well as trailers for other New Line releases. ---
|
|
Final Words:
|
Malick’s first film in seven
years misses the boat. The dialogue is corny, the performances
frequently stilted and the man who created this film is MIA
in the extras. Much like “Days of Heaven” “The New World”
is flawed but at least that film ran a tolerable 95 minutes.
Malick's unique visual sense remains in tact but the film
could have used some serious pruning. In spite of these flaws
"The New World" is a visual masterpiece with some solid performances
that just misses the mark because of the screenplay. Malick’s
visual sense never deserts him but his ability as a writer
disappears in this flawed but fine looking film. |
|
|