Review Archives

1 | 2 | 3

Today's Date is:

Old Yeller


Reviewed by: David Litton
Genre: Family
Video: 1.75:1 widescre
Audio: Dolby Digital 5.1
Language: English
Subtitle: Spanish
Length: 88 min
Rating: G
Release Date: 05/07/2002
Studio: Walt Disney Pictures
Commentary: Feature commentary with actors Tommy Kirk, Fess Parker, Kevin Corcoran and animal trainer Bob Weatherwax
Documentaries: See below
Featurettes: "Old Yeller: Remembering a Classic," "Lost Treasures: Ranch of the Golden Oak"
Filmography/Biography: None
Interviews: Conversations with Tommy Kirk
Trailers/TV Spots: Yes
Alternate/Deleted Scenes: None
Music Video: None
Other: "Dogs" montage, production archives, 1957 Disney studio album, radio spots
Cast and Crew: Dorothy McGuire, Fess Parker, Jeff York, Chuck Conners, Beverly Washburn, Tommy Kirk, Kevin Corcoran
Screenplay by: Written by: Fred Gipson, William Tu
Produced by: William H. Anderson, Walt Disney
Directed By: Robert Stevenson
Music: Will Schaefer, Oliver Wallace
The Review:

In many of today's movies, stories that involves animals as main characters usually give the animal more interest than its human counterparts. There were the three lost pets of Disney's "Homeward Bound: The Incredible Journey," the larger-than-life St. Bernard of "Beethoven," and not to mention his newly arrived family in "Beethoven's 2nd." Since much of these films' plots took place around animals, it seems only necessary that we care more for them than anything or anyone else.

It's interesting to look at movies of this particular nature in this day and age, and compare them to a classic along the likes of "Old Yeller," one of Disney's most revered and well-told tales in which we care for humans and animals alike. Telling Fred Gipson's heartwarming and heartwrenching tale of a simple life where hardships are learned with true impact and understanding, the film has endured the challenges of time and modern film to remain one of the best films ever made.

Written in 1956 and selling over three million copies by 1973, "Old Yeller" was the book Gipson considered his best work. Penning the screenplay for the movie, it's no surprise that he kept everything that remained dear to his readers intact: the distinct characterization (both canine and human), the all-encompassing appeal to the young and old, and the simplistic elements of life on the terrain that has become the center stage for tales of personal growth and hardship.

Here, we are introduced to the Coates family, who have settled on land in Texas and have made themselves a home. They lead a simple life, one involving planting of small crops for food, upkeep of the grounds and their meager yet comely home, and a devotion to family and virtue that seems but a faded memory when seen through today's disaffected eyes and minds. Husband Jim (Fess Parker) and wife Katie (Dorothy McGuire) care for one another wholeheartedly, and want nothing more than to raise their children, Travis (Tommy Kirk) and Arliss (Kevin Corcoran) with a sense of decency and respect.

After Jim departs for many months to sell off their herds for money and supply, Travis becomes the man in charge. In his eyes, we see a longing to be just like his father: hardworking, learned, and full of knowledge. Placed in the setting of the frontier, where he must work to keep up the home in the absence of his father, we see a life-affirmation in Travis, a testament of the values of morality that built this great nation, and not merely a boy tilling the soil or rebuilding a destroyed fence because his elders told him to do so.

Old Yeller, of course, was the cause of the fence's demise, leading Travis to oppose his mother's insistence that they keep the dog for Arliss to grow up with ("You had a dog as a child," she tells him, "so it's only fair that Arliss should have one."). At first, Travis wants nothing to do with the dog, but once he realizes how obedient and protective the dog comes to be, there is a friendship developed between the two that not even death could put asunder.

The great thing about this bond is its subtlety, the way it presents itself through the simplistic elements of frontier life and the actions of its characters. Old Yeller's protective attitude towards the Coates family feels more like unconditional love than natural instincts, displayed effectively in a scene where he rescues Travis from a violent pack of hogs, sustaining serious injury. At the same time, Travis himself becomes so attached to the dog that he puts his own health aside after this accident to return with his mother to Old Yeller's side and help him back home.

Dorothy McGuire is a stunner in this scene: as the mother, she keeps a stern face and a cool, sharp attitude. She knows the extent of her son's dog's injuries, and that it could cause certain death, and yet she is calm and collected, never once showing the slightest sense of hysteria or agitation. And Tommy Kirk, as the young, impressionable Travis, shows a great depth of feeling and naivety about life's hardships and trials that keeps us aware of his fragility underneath his strength. When faced with the possibility that Old Yeller may have a fatal disease, he shrugs it off with a smile, but we can see the unease in his eyes. That, my friends, is the essence of great acting.

The film's ending is a hard-hitting lesson on the tribulation of growing up, that which is saddening but enlightening at the same time. It becomes the life force of "Old Yeller," driving home the emotional connection between its two characters in a way that is simple but big-hearted, and simply touching. A great friendship between a boy and his dog has become one of the world's most cherished and beloved films, and it's easy to see why.

Image and Sound

Not the greatest of all remastering efforts, but a worthy one just the same. The image quality is that of a repaired, cleaned-up print, with colors that aren't vivid but aren't lifeless, and a clarity unseen until the movie's introduction to the DVD format. The sound quality is quiescent in nature, with surrounds that are engaged meekly, and dialogue that (appropriately) overpowers everything else around it.

The Extras

You can't go wrong with a classic like "Old Yeller," and luckily, Disney has brought it to the DVD format in a two-disc edition that is sure to please. Along with the commentary on Disc One, the movie also opens the way in which it was originally shown in theaters, with the animated short "Bone Trouble" starring the Disney character Pluto.

Disc Two begins with "Old Yeller: Remembering a Classic," which features interviews with the cast and crew on the beginnings of the book, the translation to film, and their own personal thoughts on the impact the movie has had on generations of film lovers and Disney aficionados. Tommy Kirk adds more of his memories and experiences in a section of conversations, while a montage of footage from various Disney films illustrates the numerous animal characters that have played major roles. The history of the Golden Oak ranch is explored as well, revealing the movies that were filmed there, and how it has become one of the more popular locations for filming, even today (you'd be surprised to learn that even an Eddie Murphy movie took place here).

Accompanying these are a wealth of background information on Disney and the movie, from photos and productions stills to radio spots, all of which is sure to please those who anxiously await such classics as "Old Yeller" to hit DVD.

Commentary Beginning with a commentary that accompanies the movie, we listen on as actors Tommy Kirk, Fess Parker, and Kevin Corcoran reflect on the movie, how it impacted their lives, and the lessons they themselves learned in the filming process. Animal trainer Bob Weatherwax also discusses the training of the dog used for the title character; the group provide a welcome listen that is sure to entertain and inform.
Final Words: Anyone who has fallen in love with Disney is sure to gain much joy from the features on some of its latest DVD releases, "Old Yeller" being one of its better examples.


Send all Comments to Teakwood Productions
June 4, 2002