Title: The Perfect Storm
Reviewed By: PJ Hruschak
Genre: Action
Video Format: Anamorphic 2.35:1 Widescreen
Audio Format: Dolby Digital Surround 5.1 EX
DVD Format: SS-RSDL
Language Tracks: English, French
Subtitle Tracks: English, French
Length: 130 minutes (2 hours 10 minutes)
Rating PG-13
Release Date: November 14, 2000
Regular/Special Edition Regular Edition
Region Code: 1
Studio: Warner Bros. Pictures
THX: No, (… ? … though Dolby Digital EX is a THX enhancement over the traditional 5.1 channel track whereby a phantom rear center channel is created.)
Commentary There are 3 unique commentaries available on this disk: 1. Wolfgang Peterson (Director). This commentary is hosted by J. M. Kenny who periodically guides the discussions with questions often unrelated the current scene. Peterson describes how each scene is filmed and how the sets were created. It is interesting to find out approximately how much of each scene consists of computer generated (CG) images and actual footage. Kenny is sometimes annoying since he leads the discussion away from the scene and Peterson will try to bring his comments back to topic. 2. Stefen Fangmeier (ILM Visual Effects Suppervisor) and Helen Elswitt (Visual Effects Producer). Though this commentary is not hosted by anyone in particular, the discussions between Fangmeier and Elswitt are more informational than Peterson's commentary, though a bit dry to the average viewer. This does leave some audio gaps where the films sound track is periodically raised to eliminate the awkward silence. Elswitt also becomes long winded with rambling explanations of the meetings held to discuss whether or not scenes will be shot, how they will be shot and the industry terms they often use. Fangmeier's comments are much more enjoyable and interesting, though he tends to over emphasize how the water effects were created throughout the commentary. The technical and background information in this commentary would be most interesting to film students and less interesting to the general viewer who will want to tune out after 20 minutes. 3. Sebestian Junger (Author) This is by far the best of the 3 commentaries. Junger describes the background of the town, the townspeople and fishermen. A former Glauster resident and author of the Perfect Storm novel, Junger has the most insight into the characteristics of the Andrea Gail crew and family. He openly admits where reality and story liberties are taken, such as the addition of prototypical attitudes or circumstances. His personal experiences and insights lend more to the film than any almost any other feature on the disk. Though his conversational style is a bit dry at times, listen to his comments a few scenes at a time and you will certainly enjoy the film a lot more. 
   
Documentaries "Witnesses to the Storm" includes interviews and recounts from townspeople who saw the storm and who knew members of the ship's crew, lending very personal insights into the characters and film's settings. 
   
Featurettes 1. "Witnesses to the Storm" (see Documentaries)1. "Witnesses to the Storm" (see Documentaries) The "Witnesses to the Storm" featurette includes interviews and recounts from the real people who live in Gloucester, Massachusetts. There are also interviews with former Andrea Gail crewmembers and captains. 2. HBO First-Look Special - interviews with cast and crew This is the typical HBO-style feature with quick interviews and celebrity anecdotes. This is a great summary of the rest of the features on the disk for those who do not want to watch all 6 or more hours of commentaries, images and features. 3. "Creating an Emotion" concentrates on the musical direction of the film by James Horner and how he set the mood with his score for the film. Though very short, it is well done and offers the right amount of insight. 
   
Filmography & Biography None
   
Interviews The HBO special has the most cast and crew interviews. Creating an emotion features musical score concepts of the film.
   
Trailers & TV Spots Trailer (anamorphic 1.85:1 widescreen) HBO Special
   
Alternate/Deleted Scenes & Clips None
   
Music Video(s) "Yours Forever" by John Mellencamp
   
Other The "Eye of the Storm" section also includes a Soundtrack promo, Storyboard gallery, Photo Montage and conceptual art with commentary from Wolfgang Peterson.
   
Cast & Crew
Cast

 

George Clooney, Mark Wahlberg, Diane Lane, Karen Allen, William Fichtner, Bob Gunton, Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio, John C. Reilly, Allen Payne, John Hawkes, Christopher McDonald, Dash Mihok, Josh Hopkins, Michael Ironside
Written by Book - Sebastian Junger Screenplay - William D. Wittliff 
Produced By Duncan Henderson, Gail Katz, Barry Levinson, Wolfgang Petersen, Paula Weinstein
Directed By Wolfgang Peterson
Score By James Horner

 
 
The Review:
In October 1991, a rare combination of weather conditions form the "perfect" storm known as Hurricane Grace in the North Atlantic. A fishing boat, the Andrea Gail, sets out from Gloucester, Massachusetts, to recoup the previous month's losses. The true-life drama This natural disaster film is based on actual events and features special effects by Industrial Light and Magic (ILM). The first half of the film sets the scene and helps to develop the characters so you can later sympathize with crew as the are tossed throughout the last half of the film. The love-story subplots, and some strained relations between crew members and a subtle tug-of-love-war between captains are attempts to help fill out the fairly straightforward story line. Also paralleling the plight of the Andrea Gail is a small sailboat with a prideful father at the helm and the Coast Guard's attempts to rescue the sailboat and the Andrea Gail. Even with all these underlying themes, I found the effects to often be a obvious, unbelievable and overwhelming. The crew's actual struggles with the hurricane are unclear, and this film is an obvious glorification of their plight. The early scenes of the film drag, whereas the film takes a drastic upswing and does not relent for the last half. This emotional ride is almost worth the effort, though there is little joy offered throughout the film. This is certainly a good film for pseudo-history buffs and natural disaster film fans, but is certainly not meant to be an upbeat and heartwarming experience. 
Image & Sound:
The sound is great, with each wave and creaking board being heard and sent whirling around the speakers. You can certainly tell the digital mastery in this film when listening to the waves and the special effects. The voices are sometimes pushed behind and lost to the effects, though it is not completely clear whether or not this is intended or a defect in the audio quality. I tend to believe all dialogue should be audible enough for most viewers. There are some segments where the video breaks apart and become pixelated. These breaks primarily occur during water wipe outs or underwater scenes where there are large monochrome areas on the screen. Also, the movie skips a beat between some chapters, which is the sign of either a poorly compiled DVD, or a result of the dual layering. The soundtrack is fabulously presented, so crank up the best audio system you can for this film - even consider adding that subwoofer you always wanted. 
Extra Features:
This disk is jammed with great extra features. With three commentary tracks to choose from, you can spend days learning more about the film than you even needed to know. Sebastian Junger's commentary is by far the best of the 3, and well worth the length of the film. The nearly complete filmography for each actor and the primary crew is included (did you remember that George Clooney was in the a Killer Tomatoes film?). The conceptual art gallery includes director Wolfgang Petersen narration. There are also black-and-white shots from the film included here sans narration. Scenes/Chapters: 39 scenes, still preview DVD-Rom: Available for PC only (not Macintosh) 

 
Commentary Track:
None 

 
Finals Words:
This disk is filled with enough great background information and extras to warrant at least a day or 2 to play with the various features. Though I am not a huge fan of this film, I'd recommend at least renting the DVD to learn more about the Andrea Gail. This film is definitely a great addition for Clooney and Wahlberg fan's collection. Clooney's bitter and determined captain, and Wahlberg's love-struck fisherman rookie torn between his woman and the sea (quite the sea cliché) are 2 caricatures that go bit beyond the usual scope of each actor. The full filmographies of the 10 main characters and 4 main crew members are a wonderful addition I especially appreciate. The DVD's navigation scheme is also fairly easy to follow, and the dripping water background is wonderful to help set the mood for viewing this film.