movie reviews movie review
Search Archives DVD Mall Prog Land TV Contact Us Reviewer Bio


Search Movie Review Archives

0-9 A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
 
About DVDivas
Dvdivas was founded by John Gabbard in 2000. It's purpose has been and remains to be to provide you, the entertainment community with the latest dvds and movie reviews. It will continue to be your link to the most popular dvd movies.

 

"Planet of the Apes 40th Anniversary Collection"
Reviewer:
Wayne Klein
Studio: 20th Century Fox Home Video
Genre:
Science Fiction
Release Date:
11/4/08
Special Features:

Commentary track featuring cast and crew, "Behind the Planet of the Apes" documentary, featurettes on the making of each film, trailers, still galleries, promotional material, hardbound book, timeline for the film series, Lawgiver introductions to each film ---

Review:

Fox is inviting fans to "go ape" yet again with the 40th Anniversary Blu-ray Collection of "Planet of the Apes". Handsomely if some what awkward packaged, fans get all five "Apes" films in their original configuration as well as the extended edit of "Conquest of the Planet of the Apes" that played overseas AND all the extras from the previous set. The only thing missing are the live action TV series and the animated TV series ***

The future seemed so full of possibilities in the 1960's. It also seemed like the end of the world was just around the corner. "Planet of the Apes" captured this feeling quite well. Based on the novel by Pierre Boulle author of the novel The Bridge on the River Kwai, "Planet of the Apes" became stuck in development hell when Arthur P. Jacobs couldn't get any major studio to commit to the project. The difficulties seemed insurmountable; it would require make up effects no one had been able to pull off successfully and a large budget when studios considered science fiction to be a gamble. Jacobs finally had a workable script written by "The Twilight Zone" scribe Rod Serling and a commitment from 20th Century Fox to shoot the film after he shot a scene involving Edward G. Robinson as Dr. Zaius, James Brolin as Cornelius and Linda Harrison as Dr. Zira. Cast even at this early point was Charlton Heston. The make up by Ben Nye proved that the make up effects could be done effectively. Fox still passed but eventually came round again. The problem was the budget and a third act that Serling could never quite resolve to his or Jacobs liking. Jacobs brought in black listed writer Michael Wilson (who also co-wrote the film version of "The Bridge on the River Kwai" although Boulle took credit and the Oscar at the time because both Wilson and his co-writer Carl Foreman were both blacklisted). Wilson changed the simian society to one that had a more primitive civilization comparable to the Old West from one in both the original novel and Serling's screenplay that resembled our 20th century society. With the screenplay finally finished, a design concept that was within the budget and a director who in Franklin J. Schaffner ("The War Lord", "Patton") who showed the vision to bring the film to life shooting began on one of the earliest and most profitable science fiction franchise of the time. ***

"Planet of the Apes" stars Heston as Taylor a member of a four astronaut crew traveling to a distant star. When their spaceship crash lands on an unidentified planet, the astronauts explore the area and discover a world where apes are the dominant species and man is a mute animal. Unable to speak because of an injury Taylor is put in with the other mute humans including Nova (Linda Harrison) a woman that Taylor takes a liking to. Dr. Zira (Kim Hunter) recognizes the intelligence of Taylor saving him from undergoing the knife of Dr. Ziaus (Maurice Evans) "Keeper of the faith" and the head of the Ministry of Science. ***

In "Beneath the Planet of the Apes" a second crew is sent to check on Taylor (evidently this was never planned as a one way trip at the time but the possibility was considered) with only Brent (James Francisous) surviving. Brent meets Nova and she takes him to Zira & Cornelius (This time played by David Watson). Brent follows Taylor into the "Forbidden Zone" where he discovers mutants preparing for a war with the apes. ***

"Escape from the Planet of the Apes" turns the first film inside out. Cornelius (McDowell returning to the role), Zira (Hunter) and Dr. Milo (Sal Mineo) recover Taylor's ship, manage to get it operating to escape the war and oppression and end up traveling back to the 20th century. They are befriended by the veterinarians (Bradford Dillman and Natalie Trundy) who care for them. first they are treated like celebrities but when Dr. Otto Hasslein (Eric Braeden) who came up with the theories that made Taylor's original trip possible discover the future they come from he decides they must die to protect the future for humanity. Dehn's clever script allows the satire that was a strong element of the original "Planet" to be used to skewer 20th century humanity. Dehn wisely goes after character development and action in the latter half rather than big special effects sequences (although there was an expensive special effects sequence showing Earth's destruction that was cut by Director Don Taylor when it was deemed unnecessary AND took away the surprise element of the opening. Of course, no one thought that Fox marketing would do that by showing the opening as part of the trailer essentially creating a spoiler for the surprise of the opening). The actors all give terrific performances and its nice to see Dillman cast as a good guy for a change in a sympathetic performance. Likewise Braeden hot off the success of "Colossus: The Forbin Project" (critically if not financially) cast as conflicted villain almost like a modern version of Judas. One of my favorite character actors William Windom also gives a terrific and nuanced performance as the President of the United States (originally producer Jacobs had Henry Fonda in mind for the role but Windom brings a sense of reality to the proceedings). *** "Conquest of the Planet of the Apes" was the most controversial of the original films when it was released. Director J. Lee Thompson and writer Paul Dehn decided to use the rise of the simians as an analogy for the black power movement of the 1970's. Caesar (McDowell) the child of Zira and Cornelius rallies apes that have been made domestic servants and pets after a plague wipes out cats and dogs to rebel against their masters. Governor Breck (Don Murray who gives a dark, sinister performance) sends his minions (Severn Darden among others) to find Caesar and kill him. Featuring a terrific supporting turn by Ricardo Montalban returning as circus owner Armando, this film was edited to lighten up the dark ending of the film. The original ending is included on a domestic release for the first time since it was previewed 36 years ago. Again, the budget was reduced by Director Thompson cleverly uses the then new Century City (ironically built on land that used to be part of Fox's backlot) as the futuristic city where most of the action takes place. By carefully shooting at night he's also able to make the limitations of the film less obvious. Dehn's strong script and the strong performances help salvage a film that could have been a disaster. ***

The weakest of the original series was "Battle for the Planet of the Apes" because each film had a smaller budget and although all the films performed well at the box office, Fox never gave the series the large marketing push to expand beyond the core audience of fans. So Fox felt justified by reducing the budget plus the studio was continuing to have major financial troubles. With a budget a little bit over $1 million, Director J. Lee Thompson has to create a credible battle between the descendants of the humans (Severn Darden returning to his role as Kolp when Murray declined to return as Breck). Caesar (McDowell) must create a coalition between the humans living with the apes as and treated as second class citizens to survive the onslaught by the humans. The budget of the film and the b-movie script by Joyce and John William Corrington ("The Omega Man") based on a story by Paul Dehn (who had a much more expensive battle in mind) makes this "Battle" into little more than a minor skirmish. Still, the performances particularly from supporting actors Paul Williams, John Huston and Claude Akins make the film more than it is. "Battle" looks like a stylishly shot TV movie. ---

Image & Sound: All five films look exceptionally good for their age. Keep in mind that these films were always meant to look somewhat grainy. My only complaint is that the colors aren't quite as strong as I remember them and I feel that Fox should have increased the color saturation for the third, fourth and fifth films. The first two look extremely good but the contrast is a bit too high and Fox should have lowered the contrast darkening the images a b bit. ***

Audio for all five films is strong. Keep in mind that these films were made 40 years ago and the sound will not pop like a more recent film. The music has considerable punch and dialog is crystal clear throughout the films. We also get isolated music tracks that sound wonderful for a couple of films. ---

Special Features:

Commentary tracks, "Behind the Planet of the Apes" feature length documentary, featurettes on each film some with new interviews, vintage promotional featurettes, trailers, advertising and pictures of various toys are all included as part of the special features here. These were all available on the previous set as well. ***

We also get an annoying special feature luckily Fox has enabled the Blu-ray menu to skip it. It's a CGI Lawgiver who does an imitation of John Huston from the fifth film. The Lawgiver gives a brief synopsis of each film and its themes. While it was a good idea in principle, it's a lousy idea in execution. Really, anyone who has watched these films will know these facts and those that haven't may hear spoilers about the basic plot of each film. I'm not sure what prompted Fox to include this except that it probably seemed like a cool idea at the time. ***

Finally inside there is a hardcopy book about the film series. There are numerous photos some of which were included in the documentary and some of which appear here for the very first time or for the first time in decades. It's a well written book that summarizes information found in the documentary and the book The Planet of the Apes Revisited (in fact this book is listed as a reference). It's a handsome looking book with a nicely designed outer cover. Also, on the cardboard flaps that overlap and hold the book in place there is a timeline for the "Planet of the Apes" films that is also quite interesting. Again, the packaging is handsomely designed but a bit large and cumbersome. Many fans will do well to buy some DVD or Blu-ray holders to put the discs themselves in as the discs are held inside the cardboard "cover" for the set with little blobs of rubber that are the size of a Blu-ray spindle holder. With time I have no doubt that you might damage the discs taking them in and out and the rubber will eventually wear off with wear and tear. Additionally, who wants to have to open this nicely designed package every single time you want to watch a movie? ---

Final Words:

Fox has done a terrific job on the transfer, special features and the hardbound book included with this set. While the packaging is handsome, it's also large and cumbersome and one has to question the practicality of this design since you'll find yourself having to open the set every time you want to watch the movies or look at the book. Additionally, the little rubber holders for the Blu-ray discs themselves will wear off with time and, perhaps, subject the discs to damage as they fail. I'd suggest putting the discs into a DVD or Blu-ray case to prevent damage. I'm not sure why Fox didn't do this like the multi-disc holder for "Blade Runner" AND included the book as part of the package (I know that cost certainly played a r ole BUT why design something so handsome and that will be wasted on the average consumer?) but it would be the logical thing to do. As we all know, logic rarely plays a role in home video releases. This is the third go round for the "Planet of the Apes" series on disc and I don't doubt that we'll see them all again in another deluxe package at some point but for high definition fans this should be the definitive edition for some time to come.

 

 
 
 
Copyright @ Teakwood Productions 2000
Home News DVDWorld DVDLand(Links) DVDVoices
Search Archives DVD Mall Prog Land TV Contact Us Reviewer's Bio
Upcoming DVDs In Theatres Soon Other Popular Reviews
This Page Design By Dominion Technology Provider
 
In Theatres Soon Upcoming DVDs Alias Tomb Raider Casablanca NYPD Blues